Grampians Set-Aside Determination Concerning Rock Climbing

The ACAV Committee believes that Parks Victoria displayed major bureaucratic overreach in February 2019 by instituting Grampians rock climbing prohibitions. This episode has far-reaching consequences for the public good in terms of access to public lands for everyone. There is far more to this story than contained within the legal domain and we are at a critical point for future generations. Many user groups are facing similar lockouts from public lands. 

The exclusion of respectful park users is a great detriment to park management and an opportunity has so far been missed to blend the knowledge of the Traditional Owners into genuine and collaborative park management. Respectful and knowledgeable park users are the natural allies of the Traditional Owners in seeking to bring future generations together to celebrate culture and the environment in a spirit of mutual respect and understanding.

On 25th July 2019, ACAV received this letter from the Manager, Legal Services of Parks Victoria in response to our requests for the reasons behind the Grampians climbing prohibitions.

In response, the ACAV has funded formal legal advice regarding the legality of the set aside determination used by Parks Victoria to prohibit rock climbing at various locations within the Grampians. We would like to thank ACAV members and supporters whose membership fees and donations have contributed to obtaining this advice.

Following advice from Senior Counsel, a letter from our lawyers was issued to Parks Victoria on Monday 2nd September 2019, asserting that the set aside determination is invalid and proposing that the set aside determination should be revoked. You can read the full letter here.

In simple terms the letter conveys that:

1. The climbing prohibitions are invalid as they currently stand.

2. The climbing prohibitions are “legally unreasonable” and “disproportionate to the supposed mischief to be addressed”.

The letter gives Parks Victoria seven days to provide a substantive response, without which we have instructed our lawyers to commence proceedings for a judicial review.

The ACAV will continue to provide updates on a regular basis as information comes to hand and when we have a better idea of the position Parks Victoria wants to take towards the ACAV and Grampians climbing access.

Please show your support by becoming an ACAV member join via this link

With the potential for the requirement of additional legal counsel and fees, we need your help to top up the ACAV Access Fund. To assist with the incursion of future costs, please consider giving an extra donation via this link.

The ACAV Committee would like to thank the climbing community for its continued support and commitment to resolving access issues in the Grampians.

2 thoughts on “Grampians Set-Aside Determination Concerning Rock Climbing

  1. My concern is that most/all people are aware of the legal matters at hand and information regarding this has been lax. The above letters are dated July and September. Its now 28th of October. Information flow from you guys has been pretty ordinary. We…the climbers and funders of this action deserve a more precise follow up of information. I certainly will contribute more $s, in return I think its fair that a quicker, more comprehensive explaination is delivered in a more timely way. Godspeed and fingers crossed. Lots of climbers including me haven’t been adequately informed. Keep the updates flowing so we trust in whats happening. Thank you Brett Mason. Climber since 1978. Lived and climbed in Grampians for many years..

    Like

    • Hi Brett,
      Thank you for taking the time to leave a comment. To give you an update on what the Committee have been up to, I would like to refer you to our update from 14 October. Though still 2 weeks old, it is still relevant as the Committee is still currently working on finalising all pre-trial duties before commencing our legal proceedings. The Committee is working with our solicitor and legal counsel to ensure we cross our t’s and dot our i’s before commencing these proceedings. Once we have filed, there are huge costs involved and more incurred if we have not done our due diligence prior to commencement of proceedings. The Committee wants to ensure that we use the monies from our members in the Access Fund wisely.

      A Round Table discussion took place in early October under Chatham House Rules. Participants of the discussion are still waiting on the meeting notes from the facilitator. Once received, these will be posted online for our members and the wider community to read.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s